Deflection and Deterrence: Europe’s Shrinking Asylum Space and its Parallels with Australian Policies

Gemima Harvey


In 2015, as asylum seekers, refugees and migrants began making their way to Europe in larger numbers, the European Union set about putting policies in place to shut them out and protect its external borders. In the process, the protection of borders has become paramount to the protection needs of people, and policies have been designed to contain people in regions of origin, deterring the desire to reach Europe and deflecting responsibility for processing asylum claims to states elsewhere. The framing of resettlement as a reward for countries that cooperate, and people who wait, and the shifting of responsibility onto other states, where refugees cannot enjoy full rights, are reminiscent of Australia’s approach to asylum law and policy.

Full Text:




A Articles/Books/Reports

Muzafar A, and Briskman, LR, and Fiske LI, ‘Asylum seekers and refugees in Indonesia: problems and potentials.’ (2016) 8(2), pp.22–42. Cosmopolitan Civil Societies: An Interdisciplinary Journal .

Chetail, V., The Common European Asylum System: Bric-à-brac or system?’ in P. de Brucker, V. Chetail and F. Maiani (eds), (2015) Reforming the Common European Asylum System: the new European refugee law. Brill/Martinus Nijhoff.

Chimni, B., The Meaning of Words and the Role of UNHCR in Voluntary Repatriation, (1993) 442. International Journal of Refugee Law.

den Heijer, M., ‘Extraterritorial Asylum under European union Law’, in Europe and Extraterritorial Asylum. (Hart Publishing 2012).

Durieux, JF, ‘Protection - Where - or When - First Asylum, Deflection Policies and the Significance of Time Opinion’ (2009) 21, pp. 75–80, International Journal of Refugee Law.

Fielden, A., Local integration: an under-reported solution to protracted refugee situations. (2008). .

FRA, Legal entry to the EU, (2015) .

Hurwitz, A, The collective responsibility of states to protect refugees. (Oxford University Press, 2009).

Migration Policy Institute, Study on the Feasibility of setting up resettlement schemes in EU Member States or at EU Level, against the background of the Common European Asylum system and the goal of a Common Asylum Procedure, (2003) .

UNHCR, Solutions. (2016) .

UNHCR, Legal considerations on the return of asylum-seekers and refugees from Greece to Turkey as part of the EU-Turkey Cooperation in Tackling the Migration Crisis under the safe third country and first country of asylum concept. (2016): .

B Legislation

European Commission communication 2016/385/COM of 7 June 2016 on the Partnership Framework

European Commission communication 2015/452/COM of 9 September 2015 on Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing an EU common list of safe countries of origin

European Commission communication 2005/388/COM of 1 September 2005 on Regional Protection Programmes

European Commission recommendation 2015/3560/COM of 8 June 2015 on a European Resettlement Scheme

European Parliament and the Council 2016/0225 of 13 July 2016 on Proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and the Council establishing a Union Resettlement Framework and amending Regulation EU/516.2014 of the European Parliament and the Council

European Council regulation 2014/516/EU of 16 April 2014 on Establishing the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund

European Council regulation 2013/32/EU of 26 June 2013 on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection (recast)

D Other

Aljazeera, Hungary Building Border Fence to Curb Immigration, (8 January 2015) .

Aljazeera, Hungary to Build Second Border Fence to Stop Refugees. (8 January 2015) [Accessed 8 January 2017].

Ben Doherty and Calla Wahlquist, Government to pay $70m damages to 1,905 Manus detainees in class action, (14 June 2017) .

Ben Doherty, Brutal truth of Australia's detention regime can't be written off. Not even for $70m, (14 June 2017) .

Business Standard, Baby girl among five Syrians shot dead at Turkish border, (16 June 2017) .

Caitlin Katsiaficas, Refugee Resettlement in Europe: An Important and Underutilized Protection Tool, (13 May, 2015) .

CCTV, No Passage for Afghans on Balkan Route into West Europe. (15 January 2017). .

Delcker, J., 2016. The Phrase That Haunts Angela Merkel. POLITICO, (19 August, 2016) .

ECRE, Policy Note. (2016) .

Eirik Christophersen, What is a safe third country? Norwegian Refugee Council (9 March 2016) .

European Commission, Temporary Reintroduction of Border Control. (6 December 2016) .

European Council, EU-Turkey Statement. (18 March 2016) .

EU Resettlement Network, Introduction to Resettlement in Europe. (2016) .

European Commission, Implementing the EU-Turkey Statement – Questions and Answers, (15 June 2016) <>.

European Commission, Questions and Answers: Commission calls for renewed efforts in implementing solidarity measures under the European Agenda on Migration, (2 March 2017) .

European Commission, Relocation and Resettlement: EU Member States urgently need to deliver, (16 March 2016) <>.

European Commission, Enhancing legal channels: Commission proposes to create common EU Resettlement Framework, (13 July 2016) .

European Commission, Commission presents Recommendation for a Voluntary Humanitarian Admission Scheme with Turkey for refugees from Syria (15 December 2015).

European Commission, Relocation and Resettlement: Member States need to build on encouraging results (February 2017) <>.

European Parliament, Legislative train schedule towards a new policy on migration, (2016) .

Eurostat, Record number of over 1.2 million first time asylum seekers registered in 2015. (2016) .

FRA, 2015. Legal entry to the EU, (2015) p.7 .

François Crépeau, Domino effect : Turkey’s new visa rules violate the principle of non-refoulement, (9 January 2016) .

Gemima Harvey, Syrian Families Relive their Refugee Odyssey (9 March 2016) Deutsche Welle <>.

Global Detention Project, Indonesia Immigration Detention Profile (January 2016).


Jamie Dettmer, Monitoring Group Accuses Turkish Border Guards of Killing 163 Syrian Refugees (6 December 2016) <>.

Nagy, B., The Aftermath of an Invalid Referendum on Relocation of Asylumseekers: a Constitutional amendment in Hungary. [online] EU Migration Blog, (10 November 2016) <>.

Patrick Kingsley, EU officials finalise common asylum system to resettle refugees, (13 July 2016) .

Patrick Kingsley, Turkey arrests 1,300 asylum seekers after £2bn EU border control deal, (30 November 2015) .

Mercy Corps, Quick facts: What you need to know about the Syria crisis. (9 March 2017) .

MIGREUROP, Resettling Refugees, the European Instrument for the Externalisation of Asylum Procedures , (2016) .

Reuters, Turkish troops kill 11 Syrians trying to cross border: monitor, (19 June 2017)


Rodgers, C. How the ‘Safe Country’ Concept Is Putting Refugees Out in the Cold. (2017) Refugees Deeply. .

Savitri Taylor and Brynna Rafferty-Brown, African refugees in Indonesia: An uncertain future, Pambazuka News, 3 June 2010 .

Steve Peers and Emanuela Roman, The EU, Turkey and the Refugee Crisis: What could possibly go wrong? (5 February 2016) .

UNHCR, Over one million sea arrivals reach Europe in 2015, (20 December 2016). .

Visegrad group, 2016. The Visegrad Group: The Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia | Joint Statement on Migration (15 February 2016) .