Re Georgio: An Intimate Account of Transgender Interactions with Law and Society

Katherine Fallah

Abstract


In its everyday operation, the law presumes to narrate trans stories and shape trans lives. This article shines a light on law’s claims to authority over transgender identities and transgender bodies, and offers an alternate, intimate account of one transgender person’s interactions with law and society. The stories recounted here offer glimpses into the life of Georgio. Written from the perspective of someone who has had the privilege of bearing witness to his journey, this article assembles incomplete fragments of the joys and frustrations of Georgio’s gender transition and invites deeper reflection on legal assumptions about the lives of transgender people. It represents an attempt to breathe humanity into law’s cold scripts of gender identity.

Full Text:

PDF

References


A Articles/Books/Reports

Abelson, Miriam J, ‘Trans Men Engaging, Reforming, and Resisting Feminisms’ (2006) 3(1) Transgender Studies Quarterly 15

Aizura, Aren Z, ‘Of Borders and Homes: The Imaginary Community of (Trans)sexual Citizenship’ (2006) 7(2) Inter-Asia Cultural Studies 289

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-II (American Psychiatric Publishing, 1952)

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-IV-TR (American Psychiatric Publishing, 2000)

American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-5 (American Psychiatric Publishing, 2013)

Australian Human Rights Commission, Resilient Individuals: Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity and Intersex Rights (National Consultation Report, 2015)

Bell, Felicity, ‘Children with Gender Dysphoria and the Jurisdiction of the Family Court’ (2015) 38(2) University of New South Wales Law Journal 426

Blight, Jake, ‘Transgender Inmates’, Issues and Trends in Criminal Justice (Australian Institute of Criminology, September 2000)

Burgin, Ezekiel Reis, ‘The Stone in My Shoe’, in Zander Keig and Mitch Kellaway (eds), Manning Up: Transsexual Men on Finding Brotherhood, Family and Themselves (2014, Transgress Press) 35

Butler, Judith, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (Routledge, 1990, 2011 reprint)

Bornstein, Kate and S Bear Bergman (eds), Gender Outlaws: The Next Generation (Seal Press, 2010)

Chambers, Lori, ‘Unprincipled Exclusions: Feminist Theory, Transgender Jurisprudence, and Kimberly Nixon’ (2007) 19(2) Canadian Journal of Women and the Law 305

Clarke, Victoria, et al, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Queer Psychology: An Introduction (Cambridge University Press, 2010)

Cooky, Cheryl and Sharil Dworkin, ‘Policing the Boundaries of Sex: A Critical Examination of Gender Verification and the Caster Semenya Controversy’ (2013) 50(2) Journal of Sex Research 103

Duane, A Scott, ‘Men Like Me’, in Zander Keig and Mitch Kellaway (eds), Manning Up: Transsexual Men on Finding Brotherhood, Family and Themselves (2014, Transgress Press) 127

Alan Duff, Once Were Warriors (Vintage, 1995)

Dute, Joseph, ‘ECHR 2009/9, Case of Schlumpf v. Switzerland, 8 January 2009, no. 29002/06 (First Section)’ (2009) 16 European Journal of Health Law 281

Ettner, Randi, Tonya White, and George R Brown, ‘Family and Systems Aggression Toward Therapists’ (2010) 12(3) International Journal of Transgenderism 139

Gazzola, Stephanie Beryl, and Melanie Ann Morrison, ‘Cultural and Personally Endorsed Stereotypes of Transgender Men and Transgender Women: Notable Correspondence or Disjunction?’ (2014) 15(2) International Journal of Transgenderism 76

Goldberg, Michelle, ‘What is a Woman? The Dispute between Radical Feminism and Transgenderism’, The New Yorker (4 August 2014), available at

Gossett, Che, ‘Žižek’s Trans/gender Trouble’, Los Angeles Review of Books (13 September 2016), available at (last accessed November 2016)

Green, Jamison, ‘Look! No, Don’t! The Visibility Dilemma for Transsexual Men’, in Kate More and Stephen Whittle (eds), Reclaiming Genders: Transsexual Grammars at the Fin de Siècle (Bloomsbury, 1999) 117

Green, Jamison, ‘“If I Follow the Rules, Will You Make Me a Man?”: Patterns in Transsexual Validation’ (2012) 31(1) University of La Verne Law Review 23

Green, Jamison, et al, ‘Recommendations from the WPATH Consensus Process for Revision of the DSM Diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorders: Implications for Human Rights’ (2011) 13 International Journal of Transgenderism 1

Hagen, D Brienne and M Paz Galupo, ‘Trans* Individuals’ Experiences of Gendered Language with Health Care Providers’ (2014) 15(1) International Journal of Transgenderism 16

Hanisch, Carol, ‘The Personal Is Political’ (1969), in Barbara A Crow (ed), Radical Feminism: A Documentary Reader (New York University Press, 2000) 113

Hanssmann, Christoph, Darius Morrison, Ellery Russian, ‘Talking, Gawking, or Getting It Done: Provider Trainings to Increase Cultural and Clinical Competence for Transgender and Gender-Nonconforming Patients and Clients’ (2008) 5(1) Sexuality Research and Social Policy 5

Herman, Jody L, ‘Gendered Restrooms and Minority Stress: The Public Regulation of Gender and its Impact on Transgender People’s Lives’ (2013) 19(1) Journal of Public Management and Social Policy 65

Heyes, Cressida J, ‘Feminist Solidarity after Queer Theory: The Case of Transgender’ (2003) 28(4) Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 1093

Huft, Mary, ‘Statistically Speaking: The High Rate of Suicidality among Transgender Youth and Access Barriers to Medical Treatment in a Society of Gender Dichotomy’ (2008) 28(1) Children’s Legal Rights Journal 53

Jeffreys, Sheila, ‘Judicial Child Abuse: The Family Court of Australia, Gender Identity Disorder, and the “Alex” Case’ (2006) 29 Women’s Studies International Forum 1

Jeffreys, Sheila, ‘The Transgendering of Children: Gender Eugenics’ (2012) 35 Women’s Studies International Forum 384

Kennedy, Amanda, ‘Because We Say So: The Unfortunate Denial of Rights to Transgender Minors Regarding Transitions’ (2008) 19 Hastings Women’s Law Journal 281

Kirby, Michael, ‘The 1973 Deletion of Homosexuality as a Psychiatric Disorder: 30 Years On’ (2003) 37 Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 674

Kogan, Terry S, ‘Transsexuals in Public Restrooms: Law, Cultural Geography and Etsitty v Utah Transit Authority’ (2008) 18 Temple Political and Civil Rights Law Review 673

Koyama, Emi, ‘The Transfeminist Manifesto’, in Rory Dicker and Alison Piepmeier (eds), Catching A Wave: Reclaiming Feminism for the Twenty-First Century (Northeastern University Press, 2003) 244

Langer, SJ, ‘Our Body Project: From Mourning to Creating the Transgender Body’ (2014) 15(2) International Journal of Transgenderism 66

Mattilda (Matt Bernstein Sycamore) (ed), Nobody Passes: Rejecting the Rules of Gender and Conformity (Seal Press, 2006)

Messner, Michael A, ‘Sport and Male Domination: The Female Athlete as Contested Ideological Terrain’ (1988) 5 Sociology of Sport Journal 197

Miles-Johnson, Toby, ‘“They Don’t Identify With Us”: Perceptions of Police by Australian Transgender People’ (2015) 16(3) International Journal of Transgenderism 169

Nadal, Kevin L, Avy Skolnik and Yinglee Wong, ‘Interpersonal and Systemic Microaggressions Toward Transgender People: Implications for Counseling’ (2012) 6(1) Journal of LGBT Issues in Counselling 55

Namaste, Viviane K, Invisible Lives: The Erasure of Transsexual and Transgendered People (University of Chicago Press, 2000)

Nelson, Maggie, The Argonauts (Graywolf, 2016)

Newsome, John, ‘Pope Warns of “Ideological Colonization” in Transgender Teachings’, CNN.Com (4 October 2016), available at

Porta, Madeline, ‘Not Guilty By Reason of Gender Transgression: The Ethics of Gender Identity Disorder as Criminal Defense and the Case of Pfc. Chelsea Manning’ (2013) 16 City University of New York Law Review 319

Roughgarden, Joan, Evolution’s Rainbow: Diversity, Gender, and Sexuality in Nature and People (University of California Press, 2013)

Schilt, Kristen, ‘Just One of the Guys? How Transmen Make Gender Visible at Work’ (2006) 20(4) Gender and Society 465

Schilt, Kristen, and Laurel Westbrook, ‘Bathroom Battlegrounds and Penis Panics’ (2015) 14(3) Contexts 26

Silver, Anne E, ‘An Offer You Can’t Refuse: Coercing Consent to Surgery through the Medicalization of Gender Identity’ (2014) 26(2) Columbia Journal of Gender and Law 488

Sloop, Johnm, ‘“This is Not Natural”: Caster Semenya’s Gender Threats’ (2012) 29(2) Critical Studies in Media Communication 81

Spade, Dean, ‘Resisting Medicine, Re/modeling Gender’ (2003) 18 Berkeley Women’s Law Journal 15

Spade, Dean, ‘Documenting Gender’ (2008) 59 Hastings Law Journal 731

Spade, Dean, ‘Be Professional!’ (2010) 33 Harvard Journal of Law and Gender 71

Spade, Dean, Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics, and the Limits of Law (Duke University Press, revised and expanded edition, 2015)

Stanley, Eric A, and Nat Smith (eds) Captive Genders: Trans Embodiment and the Prison Industrial Complex (2nd ed, AK Press, 2015)

Wittig, Monique, ‘One is Not Born a Woman’, in The Straight Mind and Other Essays (1992) 9

Worthen, Meredith G F, ‘Hetero-cis-normativity and the Gendering of Transphobia’ (2016) 17(1) International Journal of Transgenderism 31

Yerke, Adam F and Valory Mitchell, ‘Am I Man Enough Yet? A Comparison of the Body Transition, Self-Labeling, and Sexual Orientation of Two Cohorts of Female-to-Male Transsexuals’ (2011) 13(2) International Journal of Transgenderism 64

Yoshino, Kenji, ‘Covering’ (2002) 111 Yale Law Journal 769

B Cases

AB v State of Western Australia and Another (2011) 244 CLR 390

Carcaño et al v McCrory, Brief of Plaintiffs-Appellants, No.1: 16-cv-00236-TDS-JEP (4th Cir, 2016)

Re: Logan [2016] FamCA 87 (19 February 2016)

Re: Marco [2016] FamCA 187 (30 March 2016)

Re: Rosie (Special Medical Procedure) [2011] FamCA 63 (28 January 2011)

Schlumpf v Switzerland (European Court of Human Rights, Application No 29002/06, 8 January 2009)

C Legislation

An Act to Provide for Single-Sex Multiple Occupancy Bathroom and Changing Facilities in Schools and Public Agencies and to Create Statewide Consistency in Regulation of Employment and Public Accommodations, General Assembly of North Carolina, House Bill 2, Session Law 2016-3 (2016) (US) (‘HB 2’)

Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration Act 1995 (NSW)

Gender Reassignment Act 2000 (WA)

D Other

American Psychiatric Association, Gender Dysphoria Fact Sheet (American Psychiatric Publishing, 2013), available at

Australian and New Zealand Professional Association for Transgender Health (‘ANZPATH’), Statement on Legal Recognition of Gender Identity, available at

Australian Broadcasting Corporation, ‘Transgender’, You Can’t Ask That (3 August 2016)

Australian Government Guidelines on the Recognition of Sex and Gender (November 2015)

Australian Human Rights Commission, Sex Files: The Legal Recognition of Sex in Documents and Government Records (Concluding Paper of the Sex and Gender Diversity Project, 2009)

Balani, Sita, ‘Is it Time to Say Goodbye to the Non-binary in Gender?’ Transformation (14 November 2016), available at

Bass, Lance, ‘Why We Shouldn’t Use the Word “Tranny”’, Huffington Post blog (24 December 2011), available at

Bita, Natasha, ‘Safe Schools Coalition: Sexual Politics in the Classroom’, The Australian (13 February 2016)

Brady, Jeff, ‘When a Transgender Person Uses a Public Bathroom, Who is at Risk?’, NPR Weekend Edition (15 May 2016), available at

‘Chelsea Manning Begins Hunger Strike Protest’, Free Chelsea Manning website (9 September 2016), available at

Chelsea Manning Ends Hunger Strike after Winning Gender Surgery Battle’, The Guardian (14 September 2016), available at

Ennis, Dawn, ‘Goodbye, “Anomaly”—TSA’s New Word for Trans Bodies is “Alarm”’, Advocate (23 December 2015), available at

Ennis, Dawn, ‘Whoopi Goldberg: “Don’t Ask Trans People About Their Junk”’, LGBTQ Nation (9 September 2016), available at

Epstein, Richard E, ‘Transgender Wars’, Defining Ideas (Hoover Institution) (16 May 2016), available at

Evershed, Nick, ‘How Much are Australia’s Male and Female Sports Teams Paid?’ The Guardian (Australia) (15 September 2015), available at

Duffy, Nick, ‘Germaine Greer on Trans Women: I Could Call Myself a Cocker Spaniel’ PinkNews (19 December 2015), available at

Jacobson, Jodi, ‘Inciting Hatred and Violence: Unfortunately, This Is Who We Are As a Nation’, Rewire News (12 June 2016), available at

Longman, Jeré, ‘Understanding the Controversy over Caster Semenya’, New York Times (18 August 2016), available at

‘Matildas Go On Strike as Pay Dispute Between FFA and PFA Escalates’, The Guardian (Australia) (8 September 2015), available at

McQuade, Aaron, ‘Radio Hosts Lex and Terry Apologize for Trans Murder Comment,’ GLAAD blog (7 June 2013), available at

Medhora, Shalailah, ‘Turnbull Orders Review of Safe Schools LGBTI Program after Pressure from Cory Bernardi’, The Guardian (Australia), available at

Melody, Delia, ‘What This Trans Woman Wants You To Remember In The Wake Of The Orlando Shooting,’ The Huffington Post (12 June 2016), available at

NSW Department of Justice, ‘7.23 Management of Transgender and Intersex Inmates’, Corrective Services NSW Operations Procedures Manual (V2.0 December 2015)

NSW Police Force Strategy on Sexuality, Gender Diversity and Intersex 2016-2020 (June 2016), available at

Pilkington, Ed, ‘Chelsea Manning Starts Hunger Strike, Saying She is Bullied in Prison’, The Guardian (10 September 2016), available at

Ray, Damian, ‘“I Never Stand Too Close”: A Tran’s Man’s Feminism’, Ravishly.Com (23 December 2014), available at

Story Carter, Jeremy and Damien Carrick, ‘“Absolutely Terrifying”: Transgender People and the Prison System’, The Law Report, ABC Radio National (4 April 2016), available at

Taylor, Josie, ‘Chief Justice Vows Change to “Traumatic” Court Process for Transgender Children’, ABC News Online (Australia), available at

‘Trans Men Open Up About their Experiences with Male Privilege’, Huffington Post (20 August 2016), available at

United States Department of Justice, Attorney General Lorette E Lynch Delivers Remarks at Press Conference Announcing Complaint Against the State of North Carolina to Stop Discrimination against Transgender Individuals (Washington DC, 9 May 2016), remarks available at

World Professional Association for Transgender Health (‘WPATH’), De-Pyschopathologisation Statement, Press Release, 26 May 2010, available at

WPATH, Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender Nonconforming People (7th Version, 2011)

Young, Andrew J, ‘Personal is Political: Are You Doing Your Work? White Transmen Holding Ourselves Accountable to Audre Lorde’s Legacy’, The Feminist Wire (20 February 2014), available at