THE ISLAMIC STATE AND THE QUESTION OF CHANGE IN SHARIA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.69970/gjlhd.v4i1.808Abstract
This paper is a response to An-Naʿim’s thesis opposing the notion of the Islamic state. It begins by critiquing the premises of his arguments and goes on to propose the thesis of underdetermination of Sharia rulings by their textual sources. My main criticism of An-Naʿim is that he overlooks the potential for change in Islamic law and considers it unable to accommodate new concepts of democracy, human rights, and gender equality. I argue, in contrast, that Sharia has the potential to diverge from what is considered the literal meaning of its textual sources and accommodate new theories, concepts, and values. My argument is based on a detailed exploration of the three-step exegetical procedure through which religious rulings are shaped. Throughout this procedure, there is extensive room for any jurist to insert their own personal preferences. Based on this, I conclude that sacred texts proper do not determine Islamic legal rulings and that extra-textual factors play a more important role than the text itself in determining the content of final rulings.
References
Al-Ashghar, Omar Suleiman, Al-madkhal Ila Al-Shari'a va Al-Fiqh Al-Islami [An Introduction to Islamic Sharia and Law] (Dar Al-Nafaes, 2005)
Al-Jaberi, Abed Mohammed, Naqd al-’Aql al-’Arabi [The Critique of Arab Reason] (Arab Cultural Centre, 1991)
Al-Tabari, Tafsir al-Tabari (Dar Al-Kutub Al-'Ilmiyya, 1999)
Al-Tufi, Najm al-Din, risala fi r'ayat al-maslaha [a tretise on observing maslaha] (Dar al-mesriyya al-lobnaniyya, 1993)
An-Naʿim, Abdullahi Ahmed, Islam and the secular state: Negotiating the future of Sharia (Harvard University Press, 2009)
Bernand, M., MuʿāmalātLeiden Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition, Brill '
Bousquet, G.-H., ʿIbādātLeiden Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition, Brill'
Burton, Joseph, The sources of Islamic law (University of Edinburgh Press, 1990)
Coulson, Noel James, A history of Islamic law (AldineTransaction, 2011)
Donner, Fred M, 'The historical context' (2006) The Cambridge Companion to the Qur'an
Gleave, Robert, Islam and literalism: literal meaning and interpretation in Islamic legal theory (Oxford University Press, 2012)
Hallaq, Wael B, A History of Islamic Legal Theories: An Introduction to Sunni Usul al-Fiqh (Cambridge University Press, 1999)
Ibn Taymiyyah, Taqi Al-din, kitab al-iman [The Book of the Faith] (Al-maktab Al-Islami, 1996)
Kevin Reinhart, A, 'Ritual Action and Practical Action: The Incomprehensibility of Muslim Devotional Action' in A Kevin Reinhart (ed), Islamic Law in Theory: Studies on Jurisprudence in Honor of Bernard Weiss (Brill, 2014)
Koraytem, Tabet, 'Two Surprising Aspects of Islamic Saudi Liberalism in Public and Private Law' (2013) 27(1) Arab Law Quarterly 87
Lowry, Joseph, 'Does Shafi’i Have A Theory of ‘Four Sources’ of Law?' (2002) Studies in Islamic Legal Theory 23
Macdonald, Michael CA, 'Reflections on the linguistic map of pre‐Islamic Arabia' (2000) 11(1) Arabian archaeology and epigraphy 28
Mehta, Pratap Bhanu, 'Cosmopolitanism and the Circle of Reason' (2000) 28(5) Political Theory 619
Motzki, Harald, 'Alternative accounts of the Qur’an’s formation’' (2006) The Cambridge Companion to the Qur’an, I. Dammen McAuliffe (ed.). Cambridge 59
Opwis, Felicitas, 'Maṣlaḥa in Contemporary Islamic Legal Theory' (2005) Islamic Law and Society 182
Pakatchi, Ahmad, tarikhe tafsire Qurane karim [The History of the Quran Exegesis] (Imam Sadiq University Press, 2011)
Quine, Willard V, 'Main trends in recent philosophy: Two dogmas of empiricism' (1951) The philosophical review 20
Quine, Willard Van Orman and Joseph Silbert Ullian, The web of belief (Random House New York, 1978) vol 2
Quraishi, Asifa, 'Interpreting the Qur'an and the Constitution: Similarities in the Use of Text, Tradition, and Reason in Islamic and American jurisprudence' (2006) 28 Cardozo L. Rev. 67
Robson, J., HadithLeiden Encyclopedia of Islam, Brill'
Schacht, Joseph, An introduction to Islamic law (Clarendon Press Oxford, 1964)
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
