#It isn’t fair
The Need for Guidelines for the Inclusion of Children with Disability in Sport
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.69970/gjlhd.v13i1.1277Abstract
Sport for people with disability is frequently referred to as ‘Inclusion’. However, the anomaly around ‘inclusion’ for people with disability is that sport is not always genuinely, or truly, inclusive. Sporting opportunities for children with disability are not provided in the same way as mainstream opportunities for children, and are rarely provided to be with, and against, children without a disability in a way that is fair and meaningful. Sporting opportunities for children with disability are often provided in a way that is separate and segregated. They are often non-competitive. Many of these approaches are likely to be discriminatory, either unlawfully or wrongfully.
Human rights and domestic law provide the tools to prevent the discrimination of children with disability in sport. However, the law is not currently applied to influence the structure of sport and the resulting treatment of children with disability in a way that limits or prevents discrimination. This article argues that the current situation is not working, and that the law could be more effective through the use of Guidelines published by the Australian Human Rights Commission ‘for the avoidance of discrimination’, as provided for in the Disability and Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth).
References
Baldwin, Robert, Martin Cave and Martin Lodge, Understanding Regulation: Theory, Strategy, and Practice (Oxford, 2nd ed, 2012)
Breivik, Gunnar, ‘Sport as part of a meaningful life’ (2022) 49(1) Journal of The Philosophy Of Sport 19–36
Bula, Michael, ‘Competition for Children: The Real Issue’ (2013) 42(7) Journal for Health, Physical Education, Recreation 40
DePauw, Karen and Susan Gavron, Disability Sport (Human Kinetics, 2nd, 2005) 13
Dickson, Elizabeth, ‘Disability Standards for Education and the Obligation for Reasonable Adjustment’ (2006) 11(2) Australia and New Zealand Journal of Law and Education 25
Eime, Rochelle, Young, J A, Harvey J T, Charity M J and Payne, W R, ‘A systematic review of the psychological and social benefits of participation in sport for children and adolescents: informing development of a conceptual model of health through sport’ (2013) 10 International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 98
Fredman, Sandra, Discrimination Law (Oxford Press 3rd ed, 2023)
Fredman, Sandra, ‘Substantive Equality Revisited’ (2016) 14(3) International Journal of Constitutional Law 712-715
Greely, Henry T, ‘Disabilities, Enhancements, and the Meanings of Sports’ (Research Paper No 82, Stanford Law School, February 2004)
Grenier, Michelle, Nancy Miller, and Ken Black, ‘Applying Universal Design for Learning and the Inclusion Spectrum for Students with Severe Disabilities in General Physical Education’ (2017) 88(6) Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and Dance 53
Holzapfel, Simon and Louisa Summers, ‘An Introduction to Wheelchair Tennis for Future Athletes and Coaches’ (2013) 27(4) Palaestra 27
Human Rights Council, Final report of the Human rights Council Advisory Committee on the possibilities of using sport and the Olympic ideal to promote human rights for all and to strengthen universal respect for them, A/HRC/30/50 (17 August 2015)
Kiuppis, Florian, ‘Inclusion in Sport: Disability and Participation’ (2018) 21(1) Sport in Society 5
Krein, K, Philosophy and Nature Sports (Routledge, 1st ed, 2018)
Lord, Janet and Michael Stein, ‘Social Rights and The Relational Value of the Rights to Participate in Sport, Recreation, and Play’ (2009) 27(2) Boston University International Law Journal 249
Loy, John and W. Morford, ‘The Agon Motif: Redux. A Study of the Contest Element in Sport (2019) 82 Physical Culture and Sport Studies and Research 10-45
Mareš, Lukáš, and Daniel Novotný, ‘What is sport? A response to Jim Parry’ (2023) 17(1) Sport, Ethics and Philosophy 3448
Moritz, Dominique and Simone Pearce, ‘#whataboutme: Can the Inclusion of Gender Diverse Children Pave the Way for Children with Disability in Sport?’ (2019) 13(1) Australian and New Zealand Sports Law Journal 169177
Pandel, Hannah, ‘Healthy Competition is Good for Children’ (2015) 67(1) IPA Review 3133
Parry, Jim, ‘On the Definition of Sport’ (2022) 17(1) Sport, Ethics and Philosophy 49–57
Parry, Jim, ‘The concept of sport in Olympism’ (2020) 4 International Academic Journal on Olympic Studies 131148
Pearce, Simone, ‘Disability Discrimination in Children’s Sport’ (2017) 42(2) Alternative Law Journal 143148
Pearce, Simone, ‘The fundamental nature of sport: disability, discrimination and sport in Holzmueller v. Illinois High School Association’ (2020) 21(1) The International Sports Law Journal 7493
Pearce, Simone, Sanderson, Jay, ‘The myth of a “human right to sport”: how human rights can lead to true inclusion for children with disability’ (2024) International Sports Law Journal 124
Productivity Commission, Review of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Report, 2004) 185
Suits, Bernard, The elements of sport’ ‘The Philosophy of Sport: A collection of essays Robert Osterhoudt (ed): 48-64
Taylor, Alice, ‘The Conflicting Purposes of Australian Anti-Discrimination Law’ (2019) 42(1) University of New South Wales Journal 199200
Taylor, Alice, ‘Disability discrimination, the duty to make adjustments and the problem of persistent misreading’ (2019) 45(2) Monash University Law Review 461486
Tint, A, K Thomson, and JA Weiss, ‘A Systematic Literature Review of the Physical and Psychosocial Correlates of Special Olympics Participation among Individuals with Intellectual Disability’ (2017) 61(4) Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 302
Turgeon, Stephanie, Jessica Turgeon and Diane Morin, ‘Coaching Special Olympics: a Scoping Review’ (2023) 18(1) International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching 304306
By Holzmueller v Illinois High School Association (2018) 17-2456
L v Minister for Education for the State of Queensland (1996) EOC 92-787
Martin Wells v Queensland Cyclists Association Incorporated (1999) EOC 93-031
P v Director-General, Department of Education (1996) 1 QADR 755
Purvis v New South Wales (Department of Education and Training) (2003) 217 CLR 92
Sklavos v Australasian College of Dermatologists [2017] 256 FCR 247
Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth)
Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth)
House of Representatives, The Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia, Disability Discrimination and Other Human Rights Legislation Amendment Bill 2008 (Cth): Explanatory Memorandum; Australian Government, ‘Review of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992, Inquiry Report’, Productivity Commission (Report, 12 July 2004)
Australian Human Rights Commission, Guidelines for the inclusion of transgender and gender diverse people in sport, June 2019
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) 1989, (resolution 44/25), opened for signature 20 November 1989, entered into force 2 September 1990 (‘CRC’)
Disability Standards for Education 2005
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission No. H98/67, 24 August 1999
Human Rights Council, United Nations General Assembly, Final report of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee on the possibilities of using sport and the Olympic ideal to promote human rights for all and to strengthen universal respect for them, A/HRC/30/50 (17 August 2015)
International Charter of Physical Education, Physical Activity and Sport, UNESCO(adopted by November 2015)
The Olympic Charter, in force as from 17 July 2020 (‘Olympic Charter’) art 1
U.N. General Assembly, Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: resolution / adopted by the General Assembly, 13 December 2006, A/RES/61/106, entered into force on 3 May 2008
Universal Declaration of Human rights (UDHR), A/Res 217 (III), UN GAOR, UN Doc A/810, (10 December 1948)
Australian Government: Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, ‘Australian Government Guide to Policy Impact Analysis’ (Web Page, 17 February 2023) <https://www.pmc.gov.au/sites/default/files/publications/Australian_Government_Guide_to_Regulation.pdf>
Australian Human Rights Commission, ‘Disability Standards’ (Web Page) <https://humanrights.gov.au/our-work/disability-rights/disability-standards>
Australian Government, ‘Equity, Diversity and Inclusion’, Australian Sport Commission (Web Page) <https://www.sportaus.gov.au/integrity_in_sport/inclusive-sport>
Disability Sports Australia, ‘Wheelchair Basketball’ (Web Page) <https://www.sports.org.au/wcbasketball>
Disability Sports Australia, ‘Wheelchair Tennis’, (Web Page) <https://www.sports.org.au/wheelchair-tennis>
FIDA, ‘Welcome to FIDA’ (Web Page) < https://fida.org.au/>
Football Network, ‘All Abilities’, Play Football (Web Page) <https://www.playfootball.com.au/ncdp/toolkits/inclusive-participation/all-abilities>
Football Victoria, ‘All-Abilities Football’ (Web Page) <https://www.footballvictoria.com.au/community/programs/all-abilities>
Goalball Australia, ‘About’ (Web Page) <http://www.goalballaustralia.org/about>
Little Athletics Australia, ‘Inclusion of Athletes with Disability’ Inclusion (Web Page) <https://www.littleathletics.com.au/inclusion/inclusion-and-diversity/athletes-with-disability/inclusion-of-athletes-with-disability/>
Little Atheletics Queensland, ‘McDonald’s State Relay Championships’ (Web Page) <http://laq.org.au/mcdonalds-state-relay-championships/>
McKinnon, Rachel, ‘Participation in Sport is a Human Right, Even for Trans Women’, The Sports Integrity Initiative (Web Page, 17 June 2019) <https://www.sportsintegrityinitiative.com/participation-in-sport-is-a-human-right-even-for-trans-women/>
National Wheelchair Basketball Association, ‘History of Wheelchair Basketball’ (Web Page) <https://www.nwba.org/history.html>
Netball Queensland, ‘The Queensland Gems’, (Web Page, 2023) <https://qld.netball.com.au/queensland-gems>
New South Wales Government, ‘Athletics Come and Try days for Students with Disability’, School Sport Unit (Web Page) <https://app.education.nsw.gov.au/sport/page/1343>
O’Flaherty, Antonia, ‘New inclusive sport program 'exhilarating' for Queensland students with disability’, ABC News (News, 10 June 2021) < https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-10/new-queensland-inclusive-sports-program-aims-to-address-barriers/100202856>
Proud2Play, ‘Resources Hub’ (Web Page) <https://www.proud2play.org.au/resources>
Queensland Government, ‘Inclusion: Multi-class pathways’, Queensland Representative School Sport (Web Page, 14 May 2024) <https://queenslandschoolsport.education.qld.gov.au/inclusion/multi-class-pathways>
Queensland Little Athletics Multi class relays at State Championships. Little Athletics in Queensland, ‘State Competitions’ (Web Page, 2023) <https://laq.org.au/mcdonalds-state-relay-championships/>
Schafter, Monique and James Carmody, ‘Sporting bodies unveil policies for greater inclusion of trans and gender diverse people’ ABC NEWS (News, 1 October 2020) <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-10-01/sporting-bodies-unveil-guidelines-for-transgender-athletes/12719706>
Special Olympics Australia (Web Page) <https://www.specialolympics.com.au/about/index>
Sporting Wheelies and Disabled Association, ‘Para-Sport Come and Try Day’, (Web Page, 2021) <https://www.sportingwheelies.org.au/para-sport-come-and-try-day>
Swimming Queensland, ‘Multi-class Swimming’ (Web Page) <https://qld.swimming.org.au/multi-class-swimming>
Variety: The Children’s Charity, ‘Variety Active Kids Sports Days’ (Web Page) <https://varietyactivekidssportsdays.com.au/>
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Griffith Journal of Law & Human Dignity
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
